Located at the original Wesley Chapel site on Delaware and Market Streets in Belvidere, this burying ground’s inscriptions were copied in February 1978 by Virginia Alleman Brown. Brown’s work, compared with Roseberry’s “Warren County Cemetery Inscriptions,” includes bracketed inscriptions from stones present in 1934 but missing in 1978.
This cemetery was also known by the name of Old Market Street Cemetery.
- Belles, Sl.*; wife Ra.*; dau. d. Jan. 4, 1864 (broken stone, age missing); dau. Malinda J., d. Oct. 23, 1861, age not given.
- Butz, Philip*; wife Joanna, d. Sept. 25, 1834, aged 34.5.15. This is identical to information from Beulah Gangaware.
- Clason, G.(?) W.*; wife C.W.*; dau. Mary, d. Jan. 4, 1846, aged 1.1.6.
- Clisbe(?), Samuel C.*; wife Emeline S.*; dau. Tirza M., d. Nov. 23, 1849, aged 2 yrs. & 8 mos.
- Clishe, Tirnah, dau. of Samuel and Eveline, d. Nov 22, 1849, aged 2.8.0.
- [Coen, Moore G.*; wife Sarah A.*; son John, d. May 22, 1857, aged 40.2.15.] [Coen, M. G., “Co. H. 15th N.J. Inf.” Government stone.] Identical to information from Beulah Gangaware.
- Coen, John, s. of Moore and Sarah, d. May 22, 1857, aged 40.2.15.
- [Dailey, Solomon H.*; wife Caroline, d. Aug. 30, 1853, aged 25.3.13.] Dailey, Caroline, w. of Solomon H., d. Aug 30, 1853, aged 25.3.13.
- Deremer, Charles*; wife Elizabeth, d. Sept. 1856, aged 67.4.16.
- Deremer, Joseph*; wife Mary Ann, d. Apr. 28, 1861, aged 27.10.1.
- Evans, Wm. b. Nov. 7, 1795, d. June 14, 1834, aged 38.7.4. Evans, William, b. Nov 7, 1793, d. June 11, 1834.
- Gano(?), John*; wife Jane, “Mother,” d. Jan. 13, 1856, aged 73.9.5.
- Goodrich, H.*; wife Elizabeth, d. June 11, 1835, aged 45.5.15. Goodrich, Elizabeth, w. of H., d. June 4, 1855, aged 45.6.10.
- Houghawout, Isaac*; wife Mary*; son Abel Y., d. Sept. 24, 1850, aged 3 mos. & 8 dys.; dau. Harriet S., d. Sept. 20, 1856, aged 3(5?) mos. & 12 dys.
- Hulfish, Lewis P.*; wife Melvina*; dau. Sarah E., d. Jan. 11, 1865, aged 11 mos.
- Kinney, William N., d. Sept. 28, 1849, aged 39.5.20; wife Anna, d. Sept. 21, 1849, aged 36.5.1; son Theodore P., d. July 17, 1842, aged 2.5.28. Kinney, Thodore E. P., s. of Wm. and Anna, d. July 17, 1842(?), aged 2.5.28.
- Kinney, William M., d. Sep 28, 1849, aged 39.5.20.
- [Leefevre, Lewis Vail, b. Mar. 8, 1807, at Succasunna, d. Apr. 26, 1833, at Belvidere.] Identical to information from Beulah Gangaware.
- Linn, Samuel, d. Sept. 28, 1849, aged 39.5.20.
- Mase, Mahlon*; wife Mary*; dau. Mary Ann, d. Sept. 14, 1850, aged 1.5.5.
- [Neilson, Samuel*; wife Delilah*; son James, d. Mar. 28, 1840, aged 1.6.7] Neilson, James, s. of Samuel and Deliah, d. Mar 28, 1840, aged 1.6.7.
- [Nelson, James*; wife Delila*; son Erasmus Fish, d. Feb. 16, 1844, aged 2 yrs. & 9 dys.] Nelson, Eramus Fish, s. of James and Delilia, d. Feb. 16, 1844, aged 2.0.9.
- Pearson, Henry*; wife Hannah*; son Wm. Henry, d. July 24, 1842, aged 4.9.21.
- Randolph, Abm.*; wife Elizabeth, d. Jan. 11, 1849, aged 31.6.14. Randolph, Elizabeth, w. of Abraham, d. Jan. 11, 1849, aged 31.6.14.
- Robeson, Wm.*; wife Ahline(?)*; son — —, d. July 10, 1837, aged 1.3.1. Stone in poor condition.
- Robeson, Wm. B.*; wife Malina*; son George, “drowned,” b. July 18, 1854, d. — 3, 18–. Broken stone.
- Robinson, Theodore*; wife Malinda*; son Charles, d. Aug. 4, 1868, aged 7 mos. & 8 dys.
- Silverthorn, John, d. 1867, aged 26 yrs. & 17 dys., “in consequence of the cars running off the track, was thrown from the platform, run over by the car and killed on the Portsmouth and Columban Branch Railroad at Harst Water Station, Cou–y Tp., Lancaster, Pa., on the 9th….” Eroded stone in poor condition. Silverhone, John, d. Feb. 9, 1854, aged 26.3.17. (Killed on R.R. Wreck, on Portsmouth & Columbia branch, at Horst Sta., Conoy Twsp., Lancaster, Pa.)
- Smith, Jacop P.*; w. Ann*; son John, d. May 5, 1852, aged 14.8.5.
- [Swayze, Henry D.*; wife Elizabeth*; son William Henry, d. June 19, 1852, aged 5.8.4.] Swayze, William Henry, s. of Henry and Eliz., d. Jun 19, 1842, aged 5.8.4.
- Twyning, Jacob*; wife Sidney, d. Sept. 3, 1854, aged 35.7.16.